Xiang Zhou presents "Two residual-based methods to adjust for treatment-induced confounding in causal inference"

 

Two residual-based methods to adjust for treatment-induced confounding in causal inference 

 

Treatment-induced confounding arises in both causal inference of time-varying treatments and causal mediation analysis where post-treatment variables affect both the mediator and outcome. Existing methods to adjust for treatment-induced confounding include, among others, Robins's structural nest mean model (SNMM) with its g-estimation and marginal structural models (MSM) with inverse probability weighting (IPW). In this talk, I describe two alternative methods, one called "regression-with-residuals" (RWR) and the other called "residual balancing," for estimating the marginal means of potential outcomes. The RWR method is a simple extension of Almirall et al.'s (2010) two-stage estimator for studying effect moderation to the estimation of marginal effects. In special cases, it is equivalent to Vansteelandt's (2009) sequential g-estimator for estimating controlled direct effects. The residual balancing method, on the other hand, can be considered a generalization of Hainmueller's (2012) entropy balancing method to time-varying settings. Numeric simulations show that the residual balancing method tends to be more efficient and more robust than IPW in a variety of settings.